26
A Closer (and Different) Look at Ndamukong Suh’s Stomp
Filed Under (Uncategorized) by Beim on 26-11-2011
Every Thanksgiving day football viewer saw it, and it’s drawing more scrutiny than any football play I’ve seen in quite some time. The Suh Stomp. I’ve heard and read all the hate that’s come pouring down on Suh. People saying he’s a terrible person, or an immature child, or hate filled demon. I’ve heard it all. But you know what he is to me? A football player. I’m slightly biased being a defensive back in all of my college days, having a father who’s a defensive coordinator (and old school football type of guy), and naturally siding with the defensive side of the ball in most debates. But in this particular case, that truly does not play into my take in this article. I’m only using my eyes, common sense, and knowledge of the game of football for this one.
I am in no way supporting stomping on people or unsportsmanlike play, but after watching and re-watching the replay countless times, I assure you the nationwide crucifixion of the Detroit defensive tackle is an overreaction. What Suh did wrong was let his emotions get the best of him for a few seconds, but he should not be the only person at fault from that play. I strongly urge all of you to go to youtube and re-watch the play if you have been on the side condemning Suh for this play. Let’s take a look at the details of this few second scuffle and understand it from a football perspective a little better:
First of all, if any of you have never played the game of football, especially at a higher level such as college or professionally, you would never understand the intensity and adrenaline flowing through the veins of a player between those white lines. It is literally a whole different world out there, where every player from each team wants to dominate and destroy the members of the other team and especially the man lining up right across from you each and every play. This intensity is slightly heightened for lineman and defensive players simply because of their assignments on every play being more “violent”. You have to have that as a player. It’s a key ingredient to a successful player, an emotional “edge” some might call it. If you’ve got it and your opponent doesn’t, more often than not you win.
Now, back to Suh. When you watch the play, Suh is getting a great push on Dietrich-Smith as Aaron Rodgers let’s go of the football. Suh even turns Dietrich-Smith back onto his back foot and almost completely sideways and off balance in his attempt to rush the passer. As Dietrich-Smith falls back, Suh loses his footing and begins to fall forward. I can’t honestly tell if Suh loses his footing just from Dietrich-Smith falling backwards, or if the blitzing linebacker knocks him off balance, but either way Suh falls forward and off balance. Let me say once again that Aaron Rodgers releases the football just before Suh knocks Dietrich-Smith off balance, and thus the play should essentially be over between the two linemen. But, quite the opposite happens. As Suh knocks Dietrich-Smith back and they both lose their balance, Suh slips to his knees. Then, Dietrich-Smith proceeds to keep his grasp on Suh and attempt to shove him to the ground. They both fall to the ground a bit sideways with Suh being slightly on top. If you take a look at Dietrich-Smith on the play, he is actually holding Suh outside and slightly on the back of his jersey, but that’s all I’ll say about the fact he was holding him because offensive linemen hold on almost every play.
All of this leads me to my main point I was trying to make with several people on twitter yesterday. Everyone kept trying to tell me how Dietrich-Smith pancaked Suh and that Suh was just angry he got beat on that play. Actually it was quite the opposite. Dietrich-Smith got driven back and knocked off balance by Suh. Aaron Rodgers releases the football and two almost three full seconds of a slow motion replay go by before Dietrich-Smith attempts to slam Suh to the ground. If a quarterback got hit that late, the defensive player would get thrown out of the game in a heartbeat. This was clearly not even close to a pancake, and in fact would be considered a bit of a “dirty” play by Dietrich-Smith. But of course, no one even attempts to believe that.
Back to the play. Suh and Dietrich-Smith go to the ground with Suh slightly on top. I imagine that any defensive player would be a little upset after being hit late by an offensive lineman, and as they are on the ground Suh and Dietrich-Smith both have a hold of each other by their back collar area with Suh being more up on the back of Dietrich-Smith’s helmet. Suh pushes Dietrich-Smith’s head into the ground and probably says something to him about the late hit. I know I would. But, Dietrich-Smith still keeps a hold of Suh’s jersey as Suh is on top of him. He pushes his head two more times until Dietrich-Smith finally lets go of Suh’s jersey. Now I’m not advocating jamming another player’s head into the ground, but I can understand when you’re fired up and pissed that this guy just hit you late you might exude a little bit of anger and force towards him.
Then, as Suh finally gets out of his grasp and gets to his feet Dietrich-Smith rolls over and either attempts to grab Suh’s foot or his hands just touch Suh around the foot/ankle area. I’m not a psychic, so I don’t know what Dietrich-Smith’s intentions are. But, I can see how Suh thought he was trying to grab him as he was walking away. Again, I’m not advocating stomping on another player, but if you thought someone was grabbing at your foot after this little tussle you might react somewhat similarly. Suh truly wasn’t even looking at Dietrich-Smith when he stepped on him. He just stomped his foot in what looked to be an attempt to get out of the grasp on Dietrich-Smith. He should not have stepped on Dietrich-Smith, no doubt about it. He overreacted a bit at that point and that was where Suh’s emotions really got the best of him. He definitely should be reprimanded for that and needs to learn to hopefully walk away from something like this next time. But to crucify him for this is action is just too much.
Ndamukong Suh was not in the right. Please don’t think that is what I am saying. He could have walked away from the tussle and let it go. But like I said earlier, football is the most emotional and intense game on this planet and he was taken to the ground by his opposition several seconds after Rodgers had let go of the football. Anyone who says they would not get fired up in that same situation either has never played football or is an incredibly un-intense person. Suh should be punished for his actions, but everyone proclaiming how dirty of a player he is or he should be kicked out of the league need to look much more closely at the play and understand the emotional aspect of the game of football.